7 Comments
User's avatar
Adrian P Conway's avatar

Really enjoyed this, Jacquie. The subject hit me from a slightly different angle when studying Hume’s writings on personal identity. So much inner reality yet to be discovered!

J. M. Elliott's avatar

Thanks so much for this comment, Adrian. That's a really interesting thought, and it hadn't occurred to me. Hume was probably grappling with a similar sort of question about why the "self" isn't really a coherent, unified thing, but a collection of things that rise and fall and fight within us at different times. It makes it difficult to define "who we are," but even more fascinating to explore!

Adrian P Conway's avatar

Absolutely! And Jung’s incredible work on ‘shadow’ really opened my eyes to the seemingly inescapable identity struggles haunting us all. Love this stuff.

Lavinia Thompson's avatar

This was so interesting! I love long reads about these topics!

J. M. Elliott's avatar

Thanks, Lavinia, I’m so glad you enjoyed it! And thank you for the restack. It’s much appreciated :-)

Lausanne Davis Carpenter's avatar

Fascinating stuff. Thanks for distilling it for the rest of us!

J. M. Elliott's avatar

Thanks so much for reading! I don’t quite know how I ended up on this tangent, but it’s definitely been interesting :-)